Like any bracket, the winning team is based on their matchups and may not necessarily reflect the final rankings, so here’s a list of how each place was ranked.
A few things to add:
- The ranking method was an average score of our 8-person review team on a 10 point scale.
- We understand some places offer specialty pizzas but to be fair to all parties we did our best to place a comparable order at each restaurant.
- There were some polarizing pies. Half the team explicitly disliked romano cheese, the other half loved it.
We know we missed a few local places on this list. We tried to be as comprehensive as possible, however Omaha has LOTS of great local pizza.
Lastly – every restaurant we tried was good. There’s no pizza we wouldn’t happily order again!
What did we get right? What did we miss? Did we try the right thing? Comment on our Facebook page and let us know!
Final Scores:
View the full reviews for each by clicking here.
- 24th) Big Fred’s – 4.94
- 23rd) Brick Oven Pizza – 5.48
- 22nd) Copps Pizza Company – 5.5
- 21st) La Casa – 5.75
- 20th) Zio’s Pizzeria – 5.88
- 19th) Villagio Pizzeria – 6.06
- 18th) Piezon’s Pizzeria – 6.51
- 17th) Sgt. Peffer’s – 6.6
- 16th) Lighthouse Pizza – 6.6
- 15th) Pizza Pie Guys – 6.7
- 14th) Don Carmelo’s – 6.76
- 13th) Tasty Pizza – 6.79
- 12th) Mootz Pizza – 6.8
- 11th) Johnny Sortino’s – 6.85
- 10th) Orsi’s Pizzeria – 7.06
- 9th) Mama’s Pizza – 7.14
- 8th) Lyle’s Pizza – 7.3
- 7th) Pizzeria Davlo – 7.44
- 6th) Lansky’s – 7.87
- 5th) Mangia Italiana – 7.88
- 4th) Virtuoso – 7.95
- 3rd) Dante – 7.97
- 2nd) Noli’s Pizzeria – 8.08
🏆 Canigila’s A Mano with a score of 8.39 is the 2024 Pizza Madness Champion! 🏆
Congratulations to Caniglia’s A Mano for taking the win in this years tournament! They impressed with their high quality ingredients and great flavor.
From our review:
It’s the kind of place you’d proudly introduce to friends and family visiting Omaha, promising an enjoyable dining experience that showcases a well-balanced, flavorful pizza.
Final Tournament Bracket:
